The Nancy Drews think it’ll be season one winner, BeBe Zahara Benet. (At the end of Friday’s All Stars 3 special, RuPaul teased that a tenth queen had yet to be revealed. If you’re counting, that means /r/RuPaulsDragRace correctly predicted every single contestant for seasons seven, nine and All Stars 3, with just a few minor mistakes in season eight and All Stars 2. In a private Reddit message to Mic, robbysaur said he stopped updating the post because a close friend with ties to the show told him the final cast ahead of time, and he didn’t want to raise suspicion from the rest of the subreddit. His final All Stars 2 cast prediction post didn’t leave anyone out, but he predicted a few extra queens who weren’t on the show. Robbysaur’s accuracy claim is almost true. “For season eight, we did not get Laila McQueen because Skarlet Starlet went on a social media break - and then the day before the reveal, she said she was calling off work and really made it seem like she was on.” “Since then, we’ve only really gotten one queen wrong ever,” Reddit user robbysaur, one of the main Nancy Drews leading All Stars 3 speculation, said in a phone interview with Mic. They predicted that season’s cast with 100% accuracy.

But 2015’s season seven was the first time Nancy Drewing, as these redditors call it, became an established, mathematic art form. This whole process of uncovering which rising drag stars were going to break onto the mainstream platform of RuPaul’s Drag Race started before season six.

Cast of nancy drew season 3